Updated 2025-09-08T16:21:03Z
Share
Facebook
Email
X
LinkedIn
Reddit
Bluesky
WhatsApp
Copy link
lightning bolt icon
An icon shaped like a lightning bolt, symbolizing impact.
Impact Link
Save
Saved
Read in app
This article is available solely to Business Insider subscribers.
Become an Insider to unlock full access and start reading without delay.
Already have a subscription? Simply log in.

As part of a recent tasting experiment, I set out to compare cheeseburgers from three of the largest and most recognizable fast-food chains in North America: McDonald’s, Burger King, and Shake Shack. While cheeseburgers are often perceived as one of the simplest and most universally beloved meals, anyone who has sampled them across different restaurants can attest to the fact that not all burgers are created with the same level of care, quality, or attention to detail. Even subtle variations in flavor, texture, or presentation can lead to a dramatically different dining experience.

To conduct this comparison, I decided to evaluate a cheeseburger from each of these establishments. This was no ordinary excursion for me; although I’ve eaten countless burgers in my line of work as a food writer, this was my very first time trying Shake Shack, a chain that had only recently expanded into Canada. I approached this taste test with equal parts anticipation and curiosity, eager to discover whether Shake Shack truly lived up to the considerable buzz it had generated since its arrival, and how it would measure against the nostalgic familiarity of McDonald’s and the flame-grilled reputation of Burger King. Here is a detailed account of my impressions, with the understanding that prices vary depending on location.

My culinary journey began at Shake Shack. Because the brand only established a Canadian presence the previous year, visiting the restaurant felt like a novelty. When the doors first opened, customers formed long lines, waiting patiently for the chance to sample its signature offerings. Now that the hype had settled somewhat, I decided the time was right to find out if the food justified such enthusiasm. I ordered the classic ShackBurger, priced at 9.50 Canadian dollars (equivalent to approximately $6.80 USD). The burger came layered with cheese, lettuce, tomato, and the company’s well-known ShackSauce, to which I opted to add crunchy pickles for additional tang.

From the very first bite, I was impressed. The patty’s edges were crisped to perfection, delivering a satisfying charred flavor that balanced beautifully with the tenderness of the Angus beef. What truly stood out was how juicy yet flavorful the patty remained, never feeling dry or greasy. The toppings, from the fresh slices of tomato to the leafy lettuce, contributed both moisture and contrast. Encasing everything was a potato bun that managed to remain soft and pliant, maintaining structure without becoming soggy. The bun also carried a subtle note of sweetness that complemented the salty richness of the beef. Altogether, the burger felt cohesive, indulgent, and carefully constructed. Without hesitation, I would order the ShackBurger again.

Next, I visited Burger King, a chain I had not patronized in more than fifteen years. My lack of familiarity stems in large part from the fact that I did not grow up frequenting Burger King outlets, meaning my exposure has always been relatively limited. For this tasting, I opted for the most straightforward approach: ordering a traditional cheeseburger. In Canada, this item cost CA$4.10 (approximately $2.95 USD). True to form, the burger arrived with American cheese, pickles, ketchup, and yellow mustard atop a classic sesame seed bun. In the interest of making the comparison fairer and more consistent with the Shake Shack order, I also added lettuce and tomato.

Unfortunately, my initial impression of Burger King’s cheeseburger was not overwhelmingly positive. Immediately, I noticed the burger was excessively messy, with ketchup and mustard applied so heavily that they dominated the entire flavor profile. Instead of enhancing the patty, the condiments overshadowed virtually everything else, leaving me searching for any balance or nuance. The sesame seed bun, though airy and light in texture, carried little distinct flavor and failed to elevate the experience. The one redeeming quality was the flame-broiled essence of the patty itself, which did succeed in evoking the pleasant smokiness of a backyard barbecue. Nonetheless, the heavy-handed use of condiments made the overall effect less enjoyable, and I left feeling that it was not a burger I would necessarily order again.

Finally, I returned to McDonald’s, a chain with which I have a long and personal history. Growing up, a McDonald’s was located only a short walk from my home, and the familiar aromas drifting from its kitchen formed a backdrop to my childhood. As a teenager, I regularly ordered the Quarter Pounder with cheese, which became a staple for me during my high school years. This time, however, I decided on the chain’s standard cheeseburger, priced at about CA$5, or $3.60 USD, again adding lettuce and tomato to mirror the garnishes of my other orders for consistency.

Although McDonald’s holds a certain degree of nostalgia for me, this particular cheeseburger failed to deliver the satisfaction I anticipated. From the outset, the bun was underwhelming: rather than being pillowy and fresh, it leaned toward an overly sweet flavor profile and a texture that struck me as somewhat stale. Equally disappointing was the patty, which left behind a faint but unpleasant aftertaste that lingered long after each bite. The structure of the burger posed another issue, with toppings easily slipping out and creating a messy eating experience. Compared to my fond memories of enjoying the Quarter Pounder, this cheeseburger struck me as lackluster, and ultimately, I would not be inclined to purchase it again. It became clear that nostalgia alone could not compensate for the shortcomings I encountered.

When I evaluated the three contenders as a whole, Shake Shack emerged as the unequivocal winner. Among all the burgers I sampled, it demonstrated the best sense of balance, thoughtfully pairing a flavorful and tender patty with fresh toppings, a well-proportioned bun, and a sauce that tied the elements together without overwhelming them. The quality of the ingredients elevated the burger beyond that of its competitors, and even though it carried the highest price tag of the trio, the cost felt justified given the eating experience it provided.

In conclusion, though fast food often appears uniform in concept and presentation, this taste test reinforced the idea that execution varies widely. While Burger King and McDonald’s remain household names for their accessible menus and strong brand recognition, in my comparison they failed to rival the craftsmanship and flavor profile of Shake Shack’s ShackBurger. Ultimately, Shake Shack distinguished itself as the chain offering a cheeseburger that felt not only satisfying in the moment but also worth returning for in the future.

This story was originally published on May 12, 2025, and later updated on September 8, 2025.

Sourse: https://www.businessinsider.com/trying-cheeseburgers-burger-king-mcdonalds-shake-shack-worst-best